I’m dipping into the backlog with this review. I finished a sample pouch of this tea late last week, but as I have not had consistent access to a computer, I have held off on posting a review of it until now. I tried another of What-Cha’s Harendong Jin Xuans last month and found it enjoyable. Since I have been a fan of the very few Indonesian oolongs I have tried and was curious to see how a dark roasted version of the previous tea held up, I dug out the sample of this tea and spent a good chunk of a day contemplating it. Of the two, this one was the clear winner in my eyes, but then again, I am willing to bet that I am more of a fan of the more heavily roasted Jin Xuans than many other people on Steepster.
I prepared this tea gongfu style. After a brief rinse, I steeped 6 grams of loose tea leaves in 4 ounces of 194 F water for 8 seconds. This infusion was chased by 14 subsequent infusions. Steep times for these infusions were as follows: 10 seconds, 12 seconds, 16 seconds, 20 seconds, 25 seconds, 30 seconds, 40 seconds, 50 seconds, 1 minute, 1 minute 15 seconds, 1 minute 30 seconds, 2 minutes, 3 minutes, and 5 minutes.
Prior to the rinse, I detected aromas of honey, raisin, and plum coming from the dry tea leaves. There was something of a woody quality on the nose as well. The rinse brought out a stronger wood scent as well as new aromas of char, peach, and orchid. The first proper infusion then brought out a baked bread aroma. In the mouth, the liquor offered smooth notes of raisin, plum, and peach underscored by indistinct berry tones on the entry. These notes soon gave way to hints of orchid, char, wood, cream, and honey. Subsequent infusions brought out the orchid on the nose and I began to pick up somewhat stronger notes of char, wood, honey, and cream in the mouth. New impressions of vanilla, minerals, dried blueberry, and black raspberry emerged alongside hints of grass, cooked greens, toasted grain, brown toast, and coffee. The later infusions offered lingering notes of minerals, cream, wood, and char balanced by fleeting hints of vanilla and coffee with occasional traces of honey and fruit sweetness after the swallow.
As dark roasted Jin Xuans go, this was very nice. It displayed admirable longevity over the course of a gongfu session as well as very respectable depth and complexity both on the nose and in the mouth. The body and texture of the tea liquor were both very satisfying, as the liquor displayed an appealing smoothness while still feeling substantial in the mouth. If you are at all interested in more heavily roasted oolongs, I am willing to bet that you will find a lot to love in this tea. Even if your preferences when it comes to oolongs run more toward the greener side of things, I will assert that this tea would still be worth a try for you.
Flavors: Blueberry, Brown Toast, Char, Coffee, Cream, Grain, Grass, Honey, Mineral, Orchid, Peach, Plum, Raisins, Raspberry, Vanilla, Vegetal, Wood
Preparation
Comments
I’m not much of an expert I’m afraid. I’m more of a fairly consistent aroma and flavor evaluator that happens to have tried a lot of different stuff. A combination of experiences led me to this point. First, my parents and I have always shared a property with my maternal grandparents who took up farming prior to their retirement. They grew a variety of fruits, vegetables, and nuts every year and I always helped out in the orchard and gardens. My parents also raised a garden every year, and to them, landscaping and horticulture were and still are hobbies, so I became acquainted with a wide variety of flowering plants through working with them. Of course, I also later ended up working as a day training instructor in a greenhouse at a vocational rehabilitation center after my teaching career turned out to be dead on arrival, so I became familiar with more exotic plants through that job. In addition to all of the above, I worked in Asian restaurants, had friends and acquaintances who were chefs, and had the good fortune of going to college in a city with booming food, bar/pub, and brewing scenes. I had friends and roommates who took part in all of those scenes, and that, coupled with a sensitive nose and natural inquisitiveness on my part got me to me where I am now. A lot of it is just repetition, studying what critics describe, and trying to relate what my nose and mouth are processing to things I have tried in the past.
Practice Practice Practice is what I got from that. Alas, I have supertaster taste buds but I am terrible at identifying things that I’m tasting. Still, you should know that your tasting notes are a joy to read.
Yes, your writing is beautiful too.
Thank you for unpacking that, eastkyguy. I’ll go drink more tea now, and then more after that. :)
I just read your review after posting my own and am amazed at the similarities in experience. I have noticed how detailed the notes are in your other reviews. Tasting and noting this oolong close to your level of detail took all my energy. You’ve got a hell of a skill, guy.
I am in awe of your ability to identify flavours
^ Me too. eastkyguy, how did you come to this level of tea expertise?
I’m not much of an expert I’m afraid. I’m more of a fairly consistent aroma and flavor evaluator that happens to have tried a lot of different stuff. A combination of experiences led me to this point. First, my parents and I have always shared a property with my maternal grandparents who took up farming prior to their retirement. They grew a variety of fruits, vegetables, and nuts every year and I always helped out in the orchard and gardens. My parents also raised a garden every year, and to them, landscaping and horticulture were and still are hobbies, so I became acquainted with a wide variety of flowering plants through working with them. Of course, I also later ended up working as a day training instructor in a greenhouse at a vocational rehabilitation center after my teaching career turned out to be dead on arrival, so I became familiar with more exotic plants through that job. In addition to all of the above, I worked in Asian restaurants, had friends and acquaintances who were chefs, and had the good fortune of going to college in a city with booming food, bar/pub, and brewing scenes. I had friends and roommates who took part in all of those scenes, and that, coupled with a sensitive nose and natural inquisitiveness on my part got me to me where I am now. A lot of it is just repetition, studying what critics describe, and trying to relate what my nose and mouth are processing to things I have tried in the past.
Practice Practice Practice is what I got from that. Alas, I have supertaster taste buds but I am terrible at identifying things that I’m tasting. Still, you should know that your tasting notes are a joy to read.
He also knows how to write. :)
Yes, your writing is beautiful too.
Thank you for unpacking that, eastkyguy. I’ll go drink more tea now, and then more after that. :)
And I will attempt to pay far more attention to detail.
Thanks for the kind words everyone.
I just read your review after posting my own and am amazed at the similarities in experience. I have noticed how detailed the notes are in your other reviews. Tasting and noting this oolong close to your level of detail took all my energy. You’ve got a hell of a skill, guy.
Thank you, derk. I’m glad you have enjoyed the reviews and have gotten something out of them.