90
drank 2015 Poundcake by white2tea
314 tasting notes

From the Puerh TTB #3

One of the benefits of organizing the TTB is that I get first crack at the promotional teas. Two days ago I received a huge box from Paul at White2Tea, which was really exciting, but then I found that I already owned about 80% of the teas, so won’t be taking samples. This was one of the few I hadn’t tried.

I also want to set an example in writing reviews, so I’m posting this right away. I’m afraid the review may be a bit confusing as I’m kind of emotionallly involved with the tea. When I made my purchase for the moving day sale I went back and forth between this and the If you are reading this… and went with the latter. Then I started reading all sorts of reviews of how good pound cake was and was filled with regrets. Now I don’t know whether I’m doing a sour grapes thing (oh I bought the right tea) .

So, on to the tea. I wasn’t as excited as some of the other reviewers. I think part of the reason for this is that there is a vegetive/weedy element to the taste that while not unpleasant doesn’t add to my enjoyment. I’m mostly a black tea drinker and I think a green tea drinker would find this more appealing.

The tea is structurally sound: good nose, reasonably strong taste that blends smoothly into a good finish. Early steeps have a weedy straw flavor to a more woody style that has a lot of acidity but not much bitterness. Moderate cha qi. Not a lot of complexity in any given steep.

I have an unusual steeping style: 2 grams in 50 ml for 10, 10, 20, 30, 40, 60 s. Usually the flavor peaks at the 3rd steep, but this one kept going and I found myself liking the 4th steep better than the 3rd and the 5th better than the 4th. There is an appealing richness, and I’m noticing more complexity.

Preparation
200 °F / 93 °C 2 g 2 OZ / 50 ML
AllanK

I couldn’t decide and bought both.

mrmopar

A week in a pumidor makes a big difference on this one.

curlygc

<—- Poundcake fangirl right here.

curlygc

I am definitely a fangirl of this tea. (Btw, I have no idea why my previous comment is blank.)

Dr Jim

I’m afraid this one is going to spend 4 months in a foil bag flying around the US.

Haveteawilltravel

I stored this for a little bit, and it drastically became sweeter and more aromatic. I love this brew :)

Ubacat

I am a green tea drinker and like some of the shengs so this sounds like a great one for me.

mrmopar

Dr Jim I have some stored if you ever want to have some with the time to open up. Just PM me.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Comments

AllanK

I couldn’t decide and bought both.

mrmopar

A week in a pumidor makes a big difference on this one.

curlygc

<—- Poundcake fangirl right here.

curlygc

I am definitely a fangirl of this tea. (Btw, I have no idea why my previous comment is blank.)

Dr Jim

I’m afraid this one is going to spend 4 months in a foil bag flying around the US.

Haveteawilltravel

I stored this for a little bit, and it drastically became sweeter and more aromatic. I love this brew :)

Ubacat

I am a green tea drinker and like some of the shengs so this sounds like a great one for me.

mrmopar

Dr Jim I have some stored if you ever want to have some with the time to open up. Just PM me.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

Retired engineer/physicist.
My ratings will usually be based on multiple tastings. Oolong teas are generally 3 grams of tea in 6 oz water for 1 minute. Black teas are 1.5 grams of tea in 6 oz water for 3-4 minutes. Pu-erh is 3 grams in 2.5 oz, generally 10, 10, 20, 30, 60 sec. Since I use less tea, 6 sessions is equivalent to twice that many for people who use 7 grams of tea.

My numerical ratings are all based on how much enjoyment I took from the tea. Since I prefer blacks and oolongs, they will receive higher scores. I also give a couple of extra points to decafs, just because I can drink them in the evening without staying up half the night. I don’t dislike flavored teas, but find that they lack the complexity of finer teas.

90-100 = superior, worth a high price
80-89 = Excellent. Will buy again
70-79 = Good tea, but probably won’t buy
60-69 = Nothing really wrong, but…
Below 60 = Wouldn’t drink again. Probably didn’t finish

I am having computer problems and my password is lost. If my computer dies, I won’t be able to access my account, so will need to start a new account as Dr_Jim. This statement vouches for my new identity.

Location

Massachusetts

Following These People

Moderator Tools

Mark as Spammer