I have never tried a Puerh, and got this sample with my first and last order from Butiki teas in late summer.
I tried to look up how to brew it, since my brewing skills are so rudimentary, and got some information that it is forgiving, and can be brewed many times or even left in the pot, so I opted for the second version and decided to taste it at intervals while the leaves sat in my cup.
I did not get up the gumption to taste in the first two minutes, because it smelled like an asian grocery store with a large fish department. Not pleasant. My first sip was of that smell, plus cardboard, but with a decent mouthfeel.
After a few minutes, the tea got a little deeper golden in color, and the flavor started to be pleasantly minerally, with a silky mouthfeel and a sweetness like good well water. Not very tea like, for sure!
As the steeping progressed (like, maybe ten minutes, it was just barely warm), I started getting a smokiness on top of the minerals, followed by the minerals getting strong enough to almost taste like a fresh green bean.
Now, probably 15 minutes in, it taste like someone dipped a sweaty saddle into my previously nice and fresh oolong. It’s getting smokier and smokier, with a stronger green tea-like vegetal flavor, and a bit of drying in the back of my throat too.
This was a very interesting and complex experience, and I understand why connoisseurs really get into it, but the coin-i-ness is no longer leaving my tongue, and now that the tea has cooled completely, the fishy smell is back. My rating reflects the flavors from about 3-12 minutes of steeping, when it was like a very nice green tea. I still am not a huge fan, and I would not purchase this regularly
Flavors: Green Beans, Leather, Mineral